Article "The Great Feminization" Is Straight-Up Misogyny
Article "The Great Feminization" Is Straight-Up Misogyny
https://therepublicofletters.substack.com/p/the-great-feminization-is-straight
I read this above article recently called "The Great Feminization" Is Straight-Up Misogyny published on substack by The Republic of Letters, and written by Sarah Stein Lubrano. And this substack article is a rebuttal to the article The Great Feminization by Helen Andrews published on Compact Magazine (https://www.compactmag.com/article/the-great-feminization/)
I'm interested in hearing more thoughts about these articles from others here! There's a lot of interesting well-written points made in the substack article.
Also, someone had posted this article on Vexxed yesterday, so here is the discussion thread link, for those who'd also like to share their thoughts there as well! https://vexxed.org/o/Women/6907/the-great-feminization-is-straight-up-misogyny
TheĀ GreatĀ Feminization The most obvious thumb on the scale is anti-discrimination law. It is illegal to employ too few women at your company. If women are underrepresented, especially in your higher management, that is a lawsuit waiting to happen. As a result, employers give women jobs and promotions they would not otherwise have gotten simply in order to keep their numbers up.
It is rational for them to do this, because the consequences for failing to do so can be dire. Texaco, Goldman Sachs, Novartis, and Coca-Cola are among the companies that have paid nine-figure settlements in response to lawsuits alleging bias against women in hiring and promotions. No manager wants to be the person who cost his company $200 million in a gender discrimination lawsuit.
TheĀ GreatĀ Feminization I think people will be surprised to discover how much of our current feminization is attributable to institutional changes like the advent of HR, which were brought about by legal changes and which legal changes can reverse.
HRĀ isĀ notĀ thereĀ toĀ beĀ yourĀ friend.Ā ItāsĀ thereĀ toĀ protectĀ theĀ company When Susan Fowler found herself on the receiving end of inappropriate chats from her male manager, she documented the exchange and reported him to the companyās human resource department. Fowler, who was at the time an engineer at Uber, thought they would handle the situation. Instead, she was told to either find another team or remain in her current position and risk getting a negative performance review from that manager later on.
This was the first in a series of disappointing interactions that Fowler had with the companyās human resource department. After she left the company, Fowler wrote a widely shared blog about her experience, which triggered an internal investigation and eventually led to the firing of more than 20 employees. It also raised important questions about the way that human resources departments deal with issues like sexual harassment and discrimination. What role should HR play at a company? And why did Uberās HR department do nothing to protect Fowler?
Turns out, the role of HR was never to protect employees. Their number one priority was always to protect the company. It just so happens that sometimes the two align.
TheĀ GreatĀ Feminization Because, after all, I am not just a woman. I am also someone with a lot of disagreeable opinions, who will find it hard to flourish if society becomes more conflict-averse and consensus-driven. I am theā
1
Thanks for sharing, Dobby! Regarding the Helen Andrews original piece ā wow, is she competing to be the queen of the handmaidens? It seems she has no concept of the idea of sex vs. gender, so to her, the "feminization" of any institution is essentially just "more women are in it." She believes the biological essentialist bunk that all women are uwu soft nurturing lady-creatures, incapable of being cold, calculating, or logical. Women in science, finance, and law is bad for society because our feminine wiles will get the best of us, and our acidic vaginal discharge will somehow get on and disintegrate the U.S. Constitution, throwing the country into chaos.
She has Stage 4 internalized misogyny, to the point where she falsely believes that a system that isn't patriarchal will lead to the demise of society. Yes, it will lead to the demise of the patriarchal hierarchical society. I can think of two options on why this notion is leaving her in sheer horror:
TheĀ GreatĀ Feminization The most obvious thumb on the scale is anti-discrimination law. It is illegal to employ too few women at your company. If women are underrepresented, especially in your higher management, that is a lawsuit waiting to happen. As a result, employers give women jobs and promotions they would not otherwise have gotten simply in order to keep their numbers up.
It is rational for them to do this, because the consequences for failing to do so can be dire. Texaco, Goldman Sachs, Novartis, and Coca-Cola are among the companies that have paid nine-figure settlements in response to lawsuits alleging bias against women in hiring and promotions. No manager wants to be the person who cost his company $200 million in a gender discrimination lawsuit.
TheĀ GreatĀ Feminization I think people will be surprised to discover how much of our current feminization is attributable to institutional changes like the advent of HR, which were brought about by legal changes and which legal changes can reverse.
HRĀ isĀ notĀ thereĀ toĀ beĀ yourĀ friend.Ā ItāsĀ thereĀ toĀ protectĀ theĀ company When Susan Fowler found herself on the receiving end of inappropriate chats from her male manager, she documented the exchange and reported him to the companyās human resource department. Fowler, who was at the time an engineer at Uber, thought they would handle the situation. Instead, she was told to either find another team or remain in her current position and risk getting a negative performance review from that manager later on.
This was the first in a series of disappointing interactions that Fowler had with the companyās human resource department. After she left the company, Fowler wrote a widely shared blog about her experience, which triggered an internal investigation and eventually led to the firing of more than 20 employees. It also raised important questions about the way that human resources departments deal with issues like sexual harassment and discrimination. What role should HR play at a company? And why did Uberās HR department do nothing to protect Fowler?
Turns out, the role of HR was never to protect employees. Their number one priority was always to protect the company. It just so happens that sometimes the two align.
TheĀ GreatĀ Feminization Because, after all, I am not just a woman. I am also someone with a lot of disagreeable opinions, who will find it hard to flourish if society becomes more conflict-averse and consensus-driven. I am theā